volume one preface there are few successful commanders says creasy on whom fame has shone so unwillingly as upon john churchill duke of marlborough i believe this is true and it is an interesting historical study to examine the causes which have made so great a contrast between the glory and importance of his deeds and the small regard of his countrymen for his memory he commanded the armies of europe against france for ten campaigns he fought four great battles and many important actions it is the common boast of his champions that he never fought a battle that he did not win nor besieged a fortress he did not take amid all the chances and baffling accidents of war he produced victory with almost mechanical certainty even when fighting in fetters and hobbles swayed and oppressed by influences which were wholly outside the military situation he was able to produce the same result varying only in degree nothing like this can be seen in military annals his smaller campaigns were equally crowned by fortune he never rode off any field except as a victor he quitted war invincible and no sooner was his guiding hand withdrawn than disaster overtook the armies he had led successive generations have not ceased to name him with hannibal and cassar until the advent of napoleon no commander wielded such widespread power in europe upon his person centred the union of nearly twenty confederate states he held the grand alliance together no less by his diplomacy than by his victories he rode into action with the combinations of three quarters of europe in his hand his comprehension
of the war
extended to all theatres and his authority alone secured design and concerted action he animated the war at sea no less than on land and established till
the present time
the british naval supremacy in the mediterranean his eye ranged far across the oceans and the foundations of british dominion in the new world and in asia were laid or strengthened as the result of his continental policy he was for six years not only the commander in chief of the allies but though a subject virtually master of england he was
the head of the
most glorious administration in her history when he led europe saved the austrian empire and broke irretrievably the exorbitant power of france the union with scotland was but a feature of a period in which our country made its greatest advances in world rank and fame in 1688 europe drew swords in a quarrel which with one uneasy interlude was to last for
a quarter of a century
since the duel between rome and carthage there had been no such world war it involved all the civilized peoples it extended to every part of the accessible globe it settled for some time or permanently the relative wealth and power and the frontiers of almost every european state it outlined their various inheritances to the new domains beyond the ocean in its course it drew out matched and exhausted the life energies of the nations in the same way though not of course with the same scientific thoroughness as did the great war through which we ourselves have passed indeed there are other remarkable similarities between this period and
the beginning of the
twentieth century there was the same peril that the supremacy of one race and culture would be imposed by military force upon all others there was the impotence of europe without british aid the slow but sure acceptance by england of the challenge and the call and the same tremendous increasing development of british effort during the struggle the wars of william and anne were no mere effort of national ambition or territorial gain they were in essentials a struggle for the life and liberty not only of england but of protestant europe marlborough's victorious sword established upon sure foundations the constitutional and parliamentary structure of our country almost as it has come down to us to day he carried all that was best in the life work of oliver cromwell and william iii to an abiding conclusion in no world conflict have the issues according to modern standards been more real and vital in none has the duty to defend a righteous cause been more compulsive upon the british nation in none have the results been more solid more precious more lasting the triumph of the france of louis xiv would have warped and restricted the development of the freedom we now enjoy even more than the domination of napoleon or of the german kaiser it is usually pretended that marlborough's personal affections followed his worldly interests and changed sides and agents with them he certainly abandoned king james and quarrelled with king william but apart from these two sovereigns around whom ranged some of the supreme constitutional and religious struggles of our history and in whose circle business of state overrode private attachments his character shows an astonishing constancy his romantic love for his wife sarah during nearly fifty years of wedlock his fidelity to the princess and queen he served without a break for the thirty years from 1682 to 1712, were the keynotes of his life his main friendships and political connexions were proof against all the stresses and surprises of violent times when nothing was sure or safe he worked in steady and mutual confidence with halifax shrewsbury russell and legge for a generation godolphin was his close friend and ally for forty years death alone severed these ties the same elements of stability and continuity marked his great period the ten years of war with their hazards their puzzles their ordeals their temptations only strengthened a brotherhood in arms with prince eugene unmatched between captains of equal fame not all the wear and tear of the grand alliance nor the ceaseless friction between england and holland disturbed his similar association with the pensionary heinsius cadogan was his chief staff officer and cardonell his secretary through all bis campaigns and both shared his fortunes and misfortunes to the end yet fame shines unwillingly upon the statesman and warrior whose exertions brought our island and all europe safely through its perils and produced glorious results for christendom a long succession of the most famous writers of the english language have exhausted their resources of reproach and insult upon his name swift pope thackeray and macaulay in their different styles have vied with one another in presenting an odious portrait to posterity macpherson and dalrymple have fed them with misleading or mendacious facts neither of the two historic british parties has been concerned to defend marlborough's national action every taunt however bitter every tale however petty every charge however shameful for which the incidents of a long career could afford a pretext has been levelled against him he in his lifetime remained silent offering or leaving behind him no explanation or excuse except his deeds yet these have sufficed to gather around him a literature more extensive than belongs to any military commander who was not also a sovereign hundreds of histories and biographies have been written about him and his wife sarah many have been maliciously hostile and others have destroyed their effect through undiscriminating praise many more have been meritorious but unread it is only within recent times that the new school of writers who are reconciling scientific history with literary style and popular comprehension have begun to make headway against the prejudice of two hundred years it is with a sense of deep responsibility that i have attempted the task of making john churchill intelligible to the present generation many of his defenders have shown the highest ability and immense learning but their voices have not prevailed against the prestige and art of his assailants when in the closing months of his life macaulay was challenged in his facts in his methods and in his bias by the brilliant but unknown paget he felt strong enough to treat the most searching correction and analysis with contempt posterity he reflected would read what he himself had written his critics if he but ignored them would soon be forgotten it may perhaps be so but time is a long thing i hesitated about undertaking this work but two of the most gifted men i have known urged me to it strongly lord balfour with all the rare refinement of his spacious mind cool questioning critical pressed it upon me with compelling enthusiasm lord rosebery said surely you must write duke john as he always called him he was a tremendous fellow i said that i had from my childhood read everything i came across about him but that macaulay's story of the betrayal of the expedition against brest was an obstacle i could not face the aged and crippled statesman arose from the luncheon table and with great difficulty but sure knowledge made his way along the passages of the durdans to the exact nook in his capacious working library where paget's examen reposed there he said taking down this unknown out of print masterpiece is the answer to macaulay paget's defence of the camaret bay letter has been judged valid by modern opinion as these pages will show i could not be satisfied with it paget in fact proved that marlborough's alleged letter betraying to the jacobite court the brest expedition could only have been written after he knew that it had been betrayed already and could do no harm my researches have convinced me that the document purporting to be a letter is a fabrication and that no such letter exists or ever existed the argument upon this point occupies about four chapters of this volume upon this issue i join battle i believe that the jacobite records preserved in the scots college in paris are
one of the
greatest frauds of history they are nothing more than the secret service reports of jacobite agents and spies in england it is astounding that so many famous writers should have accepted them to traduce not merely mariborough but the entire generation of statesmen and warriors of william and anne who bore england forward
in the world
as she has never been borne before or since it is an aberration of historical technique in a portrait or impression the human figure is best shown by its true relation to the objects and scenes against which it is thrown and by which it is defined i have tried to unroll a riband of english history which stretches along the reigns of charles ii james ii william and mary william iii and anne the riband is always of equal width through it runs the scarlet thread of john churchill's life in this volume we trace that thread often with difficulty and interruption it slowly broadens until for a goodly lap it covers the entire history of our country and frays out extensively into the history of europe then it will narrow again as time and age impose their decrees upon the human thrust but the riband is meant to continue at its even spread i feel that for one reason or another an opportunity will be accorded to me to state in a manner which will receive consideration marlborough's claim to a more just and a more generous judgment from his fellow countrymen in this work i am compelled before reaching the great period of his life to plough through years of struggle and to meet a whole host of sneers calumnies and grave accusations the court is attentive and i shall not be denied audience it is my hope to recall this great shade from the past and not only invest him with his panoply but make him living and intimate to modern eyes i hope to show that he was not only the foremost of english soldiers but in the first rank among the statesmen of our history not only that he was a titan for that is not disputed but that he was a virtuous and benevolent being eminently serviceable to his age and country capable of drawing harmony and design from chaos and one who only needed an earlier and still wider authority to have made a more ordered and a more tolerant civilization for his own time and to help the future my cousin the present duke of marlborough has placed the blenheim papers at my disposal earl spencer and many other custodians of the treasures of the bygone years have shown me the utmost consideration to them all i express my gratitude also to professor trevelyan who may think some sentences i have written about macaulay a poor return for his own historical reparations but i can faithfully declare i have sought the truth i have profited greatly from my conversations with mr keith feiling whose authority on this period stands so high i am much indebted to mr m p ashley who for the last four years has conducted my researches into the original manuscripts at blenheim and althorp
as well as
in paris vienna and london and has constantly aided me in reading and revising the text his industry judgment and knowledge have led to the discovery of various errors and also of some new facts which are not included in the current versions of marlborough's life we have tried to test all documents and authorities at the source nevertheless we await with meekness every correction or contradiction which the multiplicate knowledge of students and critics will supply chartwell westerham august 13, 1933